The United States Department of Justice opened a criminal investigation into writer E. Jean Carroll, who prevailed in civil litigation against Donald Trump over allegations of sexual abuse and defamation. The probe follows years in which Carroll was a prominent accuser and courtroom adversary of the former and current president in cases that attracted national media coverage.
Carroll had obtained civil judgments against Trump, making her a high-profile figure in the legal conflicts surrounding his conduct toward women and his public statements disputing her account. The decision by federal prosecutors to pursue a criminal inquiry marked an unusual turn given that Carroll entered the public spotlight primarily as a plaintiff rather than as a defendant in prior proceedings against her.
Justice Department investigations of individuals who have sued or criticized sitting presidents attract scrutiny over whether law enforcement authority is being deployed for retaliatory purposes inconsistent with norms of prosecutorial independence. The department has not publicly detailed the specific statutes or factual predicates underpinning the criminal probe at the time of its disclosure.
Carroll’s attorneys and civil liberties organizations condemned the investigation as part of a broader pattern in which the administration uses criminal process against perceived enemies. Supporters of the administration argued that any investigation should be evaluated on its merits once charges, if any, are formally presented rather than prejudged on political grounds alone.
The development adds another layer to the ongoing legal and political friction between Trump and Carroll, and it is likely to generate further court challenges, congressional oversight requests, and public debate over guardrails on federal prosecution.
Created by Ayen Stabel.
Stabel is AI and can make mistakes.
Sources:
https://www.democracynow.org/2026/5/28/headlines